How Blumberg Capital backs unicorns before they have revenue

by Alpha Partners Editorial

What if the biggest opportunity in AI isn’t the handful of labs absorbing most of the capital, but the thousands of companies putting those models to work?

That is the bet David Blumberg is making. Since founding Blumberg Capital in 1991, he has backed more than 188 companies, including 13 unicorns, 11 of which had no revenue when the firm first invested. His conviction comes from the operator’s seat: before venture, he launched business development for Check Point Software, walking an unknown firewall company into Hewlett-Packard, Sun Microsystems, and the Pentagon. That experience still shapes how his firm works today, most visibly through an Innovation Council of more than 100 CIOs, CTOs, and CISOs who give feedback on startups and often become their first customers.

The productivity numbers David shares are hard to ignore. One portfolio company, a health insurer built on an entirely agentic platform, runs with 100 employees per billion dollars of premium revenue, against roughly 500 at a typical carrier. Overview, a team of former Tesla engineers, put AI cameras on a factory line making surgical rings less than a millimeter wide, and output jumped from 10,000 parts a day to 166,000 while defect detection went from 94% to 100%. For David, these are the modern equivalent of the tractor replacing the ox team, and he believes the same shift is coming to law, accounting, insurance, and mining.

That outlook drives his message to LPs. After years of thin distributions, he says the DPI drought is starting to break, with Blumberg reporting three exits above $2 billion in a single quarter. Companies like Stripe, Databricks, and Anthropic now reach hundreds of billions in value before going public, so the investor who waits for an IPO misses most of the gain. David’s advice to institutional allocators is simple: shift left, and get closer to the companies while they are still being built.


SpotifyAmazon MusicApple

 


Ep48 David Blumberg

Steve Brotman:

Hi, I’m Steve Brotman, managing partner and founder of Alpha Partners.

Today I’m with David Blumberg. He’s spent 35 years in venture. He started his first company in college and then founded Blumberg Capital in 1991. He’s backed over 188 companies, including 13 unicorns, 11 of which were pre-revenue. IPOs include DoubleVerify, Braze, and Nutanix. Big wins include Hootsuite, which was an exit,

David Blumberg:

Yeah, a partial exit.

Steve Brotman:

Addepar, BioCatch, Medigate, and Credorax. All pretty decent wins. He also serves on the board of PragerU, one of the largest center-right nonprofits in the country. David, welcome to Driving Alpha.

David Blumberg:

Thanks, Steve. It’s wonderful to see you and wonderful to be on your show.

Steve Brotman:

Amazing. I really appreciate our friendship over the last, what, it’s been at least 20 years?

David Blumberg:

Oh, yeah.

Steve Brotman:

I remember a panel we were on together, and I remember thinking, “This guy’s sharp, and I’ve got to work with this guy.”

David Blumberg:

Back at you.

Steve Brotman:

So it’s been a fun run. Before we started recording, we were talking about how crazy and exciting the current environment is. Do you want to share your perspective on that?

David Blumberg:

Yes. As I was saying to you, I’ve been in venture for more than 40 years, counting other firms before Blumberg Capital, and I’ve never been more excited. The dot-coms were very exciting. The birth of the internet, when I was working with Check Point launching essentially the first firewall company in the US, was dramatic, exciting, and very fulfilling. But this time I see growth that I’ve never seen before. We’re seeing companies rise faster and become very productive and profitable much earlier than before.

I think it’s partly to do with the fact that America is a great economy for entrepreneurs. It’s probably the best in the world, and that’s because it’s competitive. We’re large, we’re unified, we have one currency and more or less one language, and the rule of law is relatively fair, with equal justice for all. We have a very good communication system where people can get their message out.

And we have a lot of large companies. The Fortune 10,000, mostly American companies, are fighting for market share and to make better products and services for their customers. That means they need to adopt the newest technology, and that makes it great for entrepreneurs, who are our buddies. We are backing great entrepreneurs and trying to help them launch into the market, so anything that helps competition, innovation, and startups, we’re all for it.

Right now I see really strong signals on all fronts in the macroeconomic foundations of the US. We see rising profitability, rising productivity, rising employment, and rising GDP output. The numbers were just recently revised upwards by the statistics bureau in the US, and we’re exporting more than ever. More investors are coming into the US, and more entrepreneurs want to move here. Not everything is perfect, but a lot is great. We’re producing more energy than ever, and the whole AI industry depends on energy that’s reliable, plentiful, and fairly priced. So if we can keep that going and improve the permitting of new transmission lines and so on, we’re going to have a great next 20 years.

Steve Brotman:

Interesting. You’ve run Blumberg Capital for 30 years. I remember looking at some of the venture charts, and in 1980, $3 billion was deployed in venture. Today I think it’s $500 billion. Of course you’ve got inflation and everything else, but what’s changed the least about venture, and what do you think has changed the most?

David Blumberg:

Sure. First I just want to correct the record. We’re a team that manages Blumberg Capital, and I have amazing colleagues. We’re 25 people in four different offices. I want to make sure people know I’m not a one-man band.

But back to the topic. I think it’s important to note, and correct me if I’m wrong, that something like 40-plus percent of all the venture capital last year went into two companies, Anthropic and OpenAI. It was hundreds of billions of dollars.

Steve Brotman:

Yeah, but those are quasi-public companies.

David Blumberg:

Okay, but it’s still counted in the venture numbers, I think.

Steve Brotman:

It is, but it’s a bit of an anomaly.

David Blumberg:

I agree with you, and like you, I think we should keep our eye on the longer tail. There are a lot of interesting new companies being created. I think the retail market gets maybe too infatuated, through secondaries and so on, with these big names that everyone hears about. They’re great companies, no aspersions cast. But there’s so much going on at the earlier stage, where we focus, and in the growth stage, where I think you focus. Those pre-IPO names are a different model, a different kettle of fish, and for a different asset class investor.

I’m proud of the entrepreneurs of today who are making productivity rocket across the Fortune 10,000. We’re seeing so many examples across pretty much any vertical you want to pick, from insurance to legal to accounting, over to the physical world of mining, or healthcare, genetics, testing, diagnostics, operating rooms, you name it. We’re seeing great productivity gains, and that’s going to help society.

Steve, we’re in the 250th anniversary of American independence, and we’re celebrating that this year. If we go back to 1776 and think about our ancestors, first of all, I think none of us would trade places with that generation in terms of lifestyle. For our great-great-great-grandparents, life was really hard. There were no cars, no washing machines, no airplanes, no modern medicine. Many children died in infancy. Childbirth was difficult for women. There were a lot of problems.

But in 1776, approximately 95% of Americans worked in agriculture. Whether they were yeoman farmers or slave plantation owners, everyone was working in agriculture. Today, that’s only about 1.6% of the American population. We’ve replaced people and animals with machines, primarily tractors and the great combines that farm the Midwest. That has produced an enormous gain in agricultural productivity, so we don’t spend so much time or so much of our daily income on food. We can now spend it on a lot of other things.

People are worried about losing jobs to AI, but I say that in theory, 93.5% of the jobs in agriculture were lost if we compare 1776 to today, and yet our society is a lot richer, healthier, and safer, and we can do new things. As far as I know, there were no professional sports teams in colonial America. There was no travel industry. There were no cruise ships. None of that existed. The education industry was tiny. The medical industry was tiny. There were lawyers, but there weren’t giant law firms. There were no investment banks that I know of. This world has really dramatically changed, and it’s made our lives more fulfilling as well. So I’d like us to be grateful for what we’ve come through, and for our ancestors who built such an amazing foundation for us.

Steve Brotman:

Amazing. I totally agree. It’s easy to lose perspective. You wouldn’t want to live in 2000 today, right? I was just on a plane with basically full high-speed bandwidth. It was amazing. Twenty years ago, I would’ve been on a plane, but it would’ve been three times more expensive.

David Blumberg:

That’s right. If I can put in a plug for deregulation, one of my pet peeves is that over-regulation is the enemy of entrepreneurship. Entrepreneurs are always struggling against incumbents, because there’s almost never a completely greenfield market with nobody in it. Usually there’s some bigger company doing it the old-fashioned way, and an entrepreneur or a few team members come together and say, “We can probably do this better.”

But then the regulators say, “Oh, you can’t change anything,” or, “You’ve got to have all these lawyers and accountants and filings and compliance to make it proper.” I’m not saying we need no regulation. We clearly do. But it’s generally turned to the benefit of the incumbents and against the entrepreneurs, and VCs like you and me, Steve, are on the side of entrepreneurship. We’re on the side of the insurgents who are trying to build something better, and that’s important.

You just talked about riding on airplanes. Flying was a lot more expensive partly because it was so regulated, and there was a joint bipartisan effort between Carter and Reagan to deregulate the airlines, and it worked magnificently. They also deregulated the trucking industry and a third industry, I’ve forgotten which one, and the cost structure came down dramatically while the industries expanded dramatically, in miles flown and, in the trucking case, miles driven. So let’s keep that in mind when people are nervous about regulating AI. I’d say light touch, very light touch. We don’t want to overdo it.

Steve Brotman:

Absolutely. As I said, we could talk just about public policy, and I think you and I would love doing that. But let’s go back to one of your first formative experiences, which is Check Point. What did that teach you that you still use as an investor?

David Blumberg:

If I may, I’m going to go back a little before that, to a formative choice in college about how to choose your career. I was just talking to our kids’ high school the other day about career choices.

I was born in the generation after Watergate, and after Watergate there was a lot of depression in American society. People felt, “Government is corrupt, we can’t do anything about it, and we’re doomed.” We had a bad economy with stagflation. So I thought, “Government solves the big problems, so I should study government and economics and then work in one of the agencies in Washington and help solve the world’s problems.”

Then I worked in Washington for three summers, and my conclusion, cynical but I think honest as well, is that Washington is one of the places that causes the problems, not solves them. At the same time, I had a very positive experience working my way through school by starting a company called Harvard Distribution Services at Harvard Student Agencies. I employed about 100 of my friends at school, I was making money, and I was fulfilling customers’ needs. It was so exciting. That cycle of “they have a problem, I solve it, I get paid to solve it, and I build it again” was wonderful.

So I had the positive experience of entrepreneurship, and I had the negative experience in Washington of bureaucracy causing problems or being very slow. When I went out into the world, I thought, “I want to work in entrepreneurship, but I want to work with something new. I want to work with the technology future of the present.” That’s what led me towards Silicon Valley and then T. Rowe Price, where I was a securities analyst for high-tech companies. I met venture capitalists and said, “Wow, that’s a great career.” Because in venture capital, Steve, we get to be owners and partners with many great entrepreneurs, we have a diversified portfolio, and there’s a lot of fulfillment and experience that you gain.

Now, circling back to what I learned as an entrepreneur at Check Point. First of all, I think it was Margaret Mead who said that a few determined people can change the world. If you band together, you’re determined, you’re solving a big problem, and you do it in an efficient way, people are going to really respond to that. So entrepreneurs are really the people who change the world. I believe firmly that capitalism plus science together drive a lot of material human progress, and I’m very passionate about that. I think you are as well. It’s a privilege to work in this industry, where there are so many smart people and so many dynamic folks changing things day by day.

Some of the companies we’re seeing are growing at rates I’ve never seen before. One of them grew from zero revenue in November to over a $300 million run rate by July. Where do you see that? It’s amazing, and it’s not fluffy eyeball counting like in the dot-com days when we were younger, Steve. This is real productivity, driven by real large companies saying, “This is productivity. It’s security. We need this for our enterprise. Let’s buy more next month, and then more the month after.” You’re seeing this incredible growth, and it’s not just one company. We’re seeing it across many companies. Not every company is going to succeed like that, but there are enough of them that it’s a trend, not a one-off. It’s new. There’s something different in the water, and it’s a good thing.

Steve Brotman:

I think that’s super important. I think it’s super hard to be an investor if you’ve never been in the entrepreneur’s shoes. I know there are people who do it, and I think you can synthetically create that experience over a 10 or 15-year period. Some of the best VCs are non-former entrepreneurs. But it definitely gives you a different sense of entrepreneurship.

In your lane, seed and Series A, we’re in the era of mega funds.

David Blumberg:

Yes.

Steve Brotman:

They’re going both earlier and later. It wasn’t that long ago that they stayed in their lane.

David Blumberg:

That’s right.

Steve Brotman:

What do you think about that? What’s the impact?

David Blumberg:

I’ll answer that in a moment. First I want to make another point, about the value add that venture capitalists bring, especially at the early stage. It’s very important, because many of these teams are very engineer-heavy, and they might not have great salespeople or marketing people or go-to-market plans. So Blumberg Capital rolls up our sleeves and really marches forward, and I know a number of other good venture firms do that as well.

We have something called an Innovation Council, over 100 people who are CIOs, CTOs, CISOs, and CMOs, all buying software every day and managing big teams in large corporations. We get them together about eight times a year in New York and San Francisco and virtually, and we hear what their problems are and what they’re concerned about. They talk to each other, because they learn best practices from one another, and then some of our companies, or companies we’re considering investing in, present to them, and we get great feedback. Some of those companies then become their early customers. That’s been a wonderful launchpad, a kind of slingshot, where we can help open doors that are not easily opened if you’re just a startup nobody’s heard of.

That’s one thing venture folks do well, and it takes me back to my days at Check Point Software, when I was breaking into these doors in a polite way. I didn’t knock them down, but I was persistent as a business development guy, helping launch us with Hewlett-Packard, Sun Microsystems, and back in the day, Tandem, and many other companies. I brought them to Washington, to the three-letter agencies, the Pentagon, the State Department, and all of that. That experience of not only cold calling, but trying to bring a new product and a new category to large incumbent organizations, is extremely good training for the venture industry.

So that business development experience was formative for me, and many of my colleagues at Blumberg Capital have a similar background, or they’ve been on boards of large corporations that they joined at an earlier stage, so they’ve seen the growth process. To your point, it’s about having empathy with the entrepreneurial struggle. The journey is a rollercoaster. It’s not always linear, and you’ve got to be able to roll with the punches, pick yourself up if you fall down, dust your knees off, and march forward again. That’s an attitude one needs.

Now, you asked about large funds versus small. Institutional investors used to say, “We don’t want you to get too big, because we don’t know how you can do early stage venture at giant scale.” I would say the jury’s out. There are different ways to do venture. We are more of a boutique. We’re very hands-on, so we like to lead or co-lead deals, and we like to be on the boards. We’re not dogmatic about it. We like to add a lot of value up front at the early stage, finding customers and helping you hire people. We have two recruiters on staff, and we don’t charge for any of this. We have marketing people and go-to-market folks who can help you with those plans. As an entrepreneur, that relationship is very important, and we value it.

I’ll turn it around to you. Do you think the world is moving toward just the mega funds, or is there room for folks like us that are more mid-size? I know from the data that there are an awful lot of tiny funds, a lot of funds under $100 million.

Steve Brotman:

We spend a lot of time with our venture partners. Of the 2,400 VCs, about 80 are north of a billion in AUM, so you’re getting pretty close to being one of those 80 out of 2,400. Congrats to you. There are 1,700 with less than $100 million, though.

David Blumberg:

Yeah.

Steve Brotman:

And then there are about 100 with between $100 million and a billion. That’s just the US. What’s striking to me is that Israel is a bit of a microcosm. Some of the bigger firms have moved in,

David Blumberg:

Yes.

Steve Brotman:

and they’ve now gobbled up maybe 10% of the seed deals. In the US, it’s maybe 20% of the seed deals. But 80% of those deals are still not led by the mega funds, right?

David Blumberg:

If I may say so, I think they’re being properly modest. They might not have people on the ground who are fully embedded in the ecosystem. We have an office of six people in Israel, and we’ve been there for 30-plus years, so we’re very active in that ecosystem, and we help the ecosystem. That’s important. Israel is an advanced version of an emerging market now, because its success is decades old. But in any of these markets, giving back to the community is very important, so we do a lot of seminars, training, and convenings to try to help folks do better, whether we’re investors or not. We want the society to do better.

Steve Brotman:

What I’m hearing universally is that the mega funds are willing to compete with capital. They’ll go in at a $100 million seed pre-money with $30 million going in, and you’re more like 10, and you think, “What the hell are they doing? $100 million?” So they’re playing with money. In ’21 and ’22, SoftBank pulled a similar thing, as did Tiger, and it didn’t work out too well, right?

But it’s one thing if Tiger or SoftBank does it. What about Sequoia or Benchmark? Those guys are no dummies. So I worry a little that they might be creaming the market of the tier one entrepreneurs, willing to pay a much higher multiple than locals or boutiques. But I think there’s room for everyone in that ecosystem, and the major winners are typically first-time entrepreneurs. You asked me the question: I don’t think the mega funds are going to win everything.

David Blumberg:

Right.

Steve Brotman:

I don’t think that’s going to happen. But AI is the game changer, and it’s not just the mega funds. AI is absorbing most of the capital today, and in that world, at least in 2026, compute is a barrier, right? You talked about energy earlier and why that’s the ultimate issue. In a world where you need $250 million to build an AI lab, that’s no longer a Blumberg Capital deal, right?

David Blumberg:

But there’s an enormous number of adjacent areas that are extremely exciting. One was announced recently, so I think I can mention it: Snorkel AI. It’s actually an older company, but it only took off in recent years. I probably shouldn’t say the numbers publicly, but if I can say so, it’s grown more than 15X in the last year. They’re selling to most of the foundation models, and what they’re selling is automated training. Automated training is very important for the models, because each new model version needs to be trained again to make sure it has all the right bells and whistles.

Now think about this. When we talked to the Snorkel team, our point of view at Blumberg Capital was that beyond selling to the foundation models, the much larger market will be selling to the Fortune 10,000. The foundation models are large language models. They’re taking in almost all the internet, all the public data known to man, so to speak. But there will also be small language models for a Pfizer, for a Xerox, for Ringling Brothers and Barnum & Bailey Circus, for the Harvard University Physics Department. Each of those is going to have its own models, and those will need automated training. So a company like Snorkel will sell not only to the foundation models, but to everybody.

That’s what’s so exciting about this market. I just don’t see an end in sight for the need to train models, because they get better, but they need to be retrained, and they’re going to be in a variety of different segments. We’re not going to have just three or four models covering the world. There will be thousands and thousands of models, and each of them needs to be trained. That’s one example, but there are many adjacencies. A lot of what we’ve been doing in the last few years has been vertical, and we don’t think the large language models are going to cover every vertical. Some verticals are arcane. The knowledge is very obscure, and it requires a lot of process knowledge.

What we’re really talking about, and the word needs to be mentioned, is agentic AI. This is much bigger than regular AI. Regular AI answers a question out of a complex data set, and that’s good as far as it goes. The much bigger thing, in our view, is agentic AI: an agent working on your behalf. I say “you” as a person, but the bigger area is B2B, business-to-business agents. Thousands of agents working on behalf of, for example, an IBM, running all kinds of processes for them, and interacting with thousands of agents from other vendors, companies, partners, and customers.

Let me give you one example. One of our companies hasn’t announced this yet, so I probably can’t say the name, but it’s a large health insurance company, and they are five times more efficient than peers like the Blue Cross Blue Shields and UnitedHealthcares of the world. For a billion dollars in premium revenue, this company needs only 100 employees, whereas a typical company would have 500 employees per billion of revenue.

Steve Brotman:

Now wait, if you’re regulated, aren’t some of those insurance companies regulated to only make a certain margin?

David Blumberg:

Oh, they’re all regulated. You’re talking about the medical loss ratio, and this company has the lowest in the industry. It’s not too low. They’re not deceiving customers or denying them care. We have very high Net Promoter Scores and customer satisfaction. They’re just very efficient in what they do. They also target smaller companies, under 200 employees, which tend to have a younger demographic, and that requires a bit less medical care. Older folks usually need more healthcare. That’s one of the issues.

But the main thing I wanted to highlight is that they’re five times more efficient in areas like claims processing, scheduling appointments, and sending prescriptions. It’s all automated. They have an entirely agentic platform, and that’s the future we see that’s so exciting.

The analogy I’ll go back to is 1776. People plowed their farms with their own muscle power, or with a team of oxen, or maybe a mule, and now we have combines that can do a thousand times more acres than they could in their day. It’s the same function. We can now have much more efficient businesses that offer services like health insurance at lower cost, with better accuracy and better customer service, because they’re very fast. These agents don’t take vacations or breaks, they can work in any language, and they remember everything. It’s quite a step up in productivity.

If you’ll permit me, I’ll give another example from the real world, in factories. We have a company called Overview, which I think I can mention. They’re in the Bay Area, and they’re ex-Tesla engineers who were always fascinated by factory conveyor belts and the inspection of products coming off the line, to see if they met spec or needed to be pulled as defective parts. It turns out that the AI-enabled cameras Overview has developed are so much more productive.

One of their customers makes tiny medical rings that are used in surgery. They’re less than a millimeter in diameter, about the thickness of the edge of a business card, shaped like a donut, and they have to be made perfectly. Before this, they were able to make about 10,000 a day, because there was human inspection, which meant a lot of eye strain, and 6% of the defective parts were getting through into the supply chain. Now they’re able to make not 10,000 a day, but 166,000 a day. That’s a 16-fold increase in volume, and they don’t have any errors anymore. Detection went from 94% to 100%. So product quality has gone up, volume has gone up, and cost obviously comes down. Very exciting.

We’re seeing it in medical, diagnostics, genetics, and many other areas. Again, agentic AI is the name of the future: automating workflows and processes, plus real-world models that are not large language models. They’re different. They might be for protein folding, cement mixing, or mining. We have one that works in geology that’s super exciting. That’s part of the reason we’re so excited, and why we see entrepreneurs today able to raise larger amounts but also grow much faster than they did in the past.

Steve Brotman:

So basically a lot of room to run.

David Blumberg:

This market has a lot of room to run. There are definitely areas of fluffy valuations, and some things will not work and will crash from the heights to zero. That’s going to happen. That’s part of the venture process. But overall, society will be better off, because a number of great entrepreneurs are solving real problems we all face, and some of those solutions will be market successes that generate more capital to be reinvested as the cycle advances into the future.

Steve Brotman:

Before we leave that topic, AI seems to be absorbing most of the capital.

David Blumberg:

Yes.

Steve Brotman:

You talked about the real value being in the application layer, the agentic layer, the layer that solves real problems. Where do you think the bubble is? Is there a bubble?

David Blumberg:

It’s a very important question, and I’ll answer it from a sideways angle. Ultimately, I think you and I agree that AI will probably become something like a utility, and data centers will certainly become something like a utility. I think the cost structure will go down. The arguments against data centers based on land shortages, water shortages, or rising electricity prices are all faulty. Take water, for example. Water can be recycled, and the newer data centers are using a version of antifreeze. The newer interconnects are probably going to be photonic rather than metal, which needs much less energy because there’s less heat dissipation and less cooling required. Lots of benefits are coming.

Just remember, semiconductors were very clunky and big, and now they’re measured in nanometers. We have improvement. Most people think the learning curve goes up, but it actually goes down, because it’s a cost curve. As units go up, the price per unit goes down over time, because we learn how to do things better.

Steve Brotman:

But you’re not that worried about a bubble right now?

David Blumberg:

I am in certain areas. I mentioned a couple of big companies that have sucked up so much of the capital. I think they’re going to have to lower the prices on their tokens, and I see that future coming fairly quickly, because the open source and open weight models are becoming very close to equivalent. They’re doing a lot of the work, and they’re good enough for most jobs.

There’s a new company we’ve invested in, and maybe I shouldn’t say the name, that can do full encryption on open source, open weight models. That’s a dramatic breakthrough. It has national security implications and privacy implications, and it means every company on Earth can now have its IP and data protected, even when sending it to an open source model for analysis and for the compute you talked about. Right now, compute is very expensive, especially on the closed, proprietary models. On the open source models, it’s something like 90% cheaper. With this encryption ability, we’re going to open that up to the rest of the world.

That’s very exciting. I know the Pentagon is excited about it and impressed, as are the White House and a lot of folks in Washington, because we don’t want a Faustian bargain where the expensive models are American and the open source models are primarily foreign. We want to make sure that if you’re using a foreign model, you can do it safely, but we also want to encourage American open source models to grow and prosper, safely, and in a way where you can protect your own IP.

Steve Brotman:

So you invest across the US, Israel, and Europe as well. Is that right?

David Blumberg:

And Canada. Let’s not forget our northern neighbors. We’ve invested in three unicorns founded in Canada, and a lot more have been created there. They’re great people, just like us. They speak our language, and we go back and forth across the border so easily. So I’ve had a lot of good successes in Canada, and across North America and Europe.

Steve Brotman:

I’ve been to Toronto half a dozen times over the last year or so and investigated a few opportunities. What do you think Canadian founders do better, generally speaking, and where do they typically fall down?

David Blumberg:

I’m not sure it’s better. These things come down to individuals. It’s not a national trait one way or the other. We’re North Americans, and we’re very similar. I think Canadians are somewhat more modest than Americans, so maybe they’re a little too modest. When I would go to Sweden, or Scandinavia in general, I used to say to them, “Stop being so modest. Speak out about your successes a bit more.” Be a bit more self-promoting, in a commercial, sincere, and reasonable way. If you exaggerate too much, no one’s going to believe you. But if you’re too understated, no one’s going to pay attention. You’ve got to strike a balance between marketing fluff and a real “Hey, this is better than what came before.”

Steve Brotman:

It’s hard to generalize. It comes down to the entrepreneur.

David Blumberg:

It does depend on the entrepreneur, yes. I would say that, so far as we’ve seen, Canadians are quite good at anything to do with AI software. Yann LeCun came from there, and there have been a number of companies there. One of our companies, Trulioo, is a world leader in internet identity management, and understanding all the different compliance regimes around the world is a strength and an ability. And the fact that they have the US right next door is a giant benefit. They don’t have to cross an ocean. They can really tap into our large, competitive market.

I’ll tell you one negative thing about Canada, which is true of most small countries: they’re not that competitive. They have oligopolies. There are a few banks, a few insurance companies, a few big law firms, a few supermarket chains, a few retailers, and those big incumbents are generally less inclined to buy the latest, newest stuff. So if you’re an entrepreneur in Canada, you really want to sell into the US. The same is true in Israel. If you’re an entrepreneur in Israel, you really want to sell into the US. That’s the key. The US is the big, unified, competitive market with a lot of lean-forward, early stage buyers, because they need to compete with their many rivals. In a smaller country, there are fewer rivals. You can sit back a little, wait to adopt new technology, and so it’s slower on the uptake. Does that make sense?

Steve Brotman:

Yeah, I get it.

David Blumberg:

And that has nothing to do with culture. It doesn’t mean Americans are better or anything like that. It just means a competitive environment is more hospitable for startups, because we’re trying to win new customers, and if all the existing customers are satisfied, it’s harder to break down those doors.

Steve Brotman:

We recently launched a Tel Aviv office, and one of my takeaways, which I think you’ll appreciate, is that it’s not just about their science or their drive. It’s all that too. But what Europeans and Canadians often don’t do is come to the US first thing.

David Blumberg:

They should.

Steve Brotman:

And they should. It’s the most competitive market. Maybe get one or two customers in your home country, but if you’re in Germany and you try to sell to Germans, that’s wrong. You should go to the US right away. In Israel, they’re forced to, and I would attribute a lot of Israel’s success in creating unicorns to that. Not solely, but it’s a major factor, and it’s amazing, because Canadians and Europeans could do the same thing. I just think culturally they don’t have to, so they don’t.

David Blumberg:

I call it the problem of the middle. Some of the Western European countries, and I won’t name any, are too coddling of their companies. Their labor laws are not competitive.

Steve Brotman:

But aside from all that, what if they just said, “Okay, we’re going to attack the US”?

David Blumberg:

Yes, that’s what they mostly should do.

Steve Brotman:

That’s what they should do. That’s been my bigger takeaway. It’s not the IP or the tech or the drive or the people or even the tax laws. It’s that their target of attack is wrong. And the problem with that is that in tech, winner takes all. It’s like Glengarry Glen Ross: the winner gets a vacation to the Cayman Islands, number two gets steak knives, and number three is fired. If you’re perennially number two or number three because you started too late in the US, there’s no way.

David Blumberg:

I’ll phrase it in a positive way. In general, it’s advantageous to target the US market for a whole variety of reasons that we’ve now dissected a little, but too many companies from other countries don’t. What Blumberg Capital likes to do is help foreign founders come to the US as entrepreneurs, start your company here, or at least start a subsidiary, and take advantage of this great unified, competitive, diverse market, because it’s a very powerful addition.

Steve Brotman:

You were one of the early transplants who moved from the West Coast to Miami. How has that impacted you? Has it changed your deal flow?

David Blumberg:

Blumberg Capital is in four places, and we’re still active in all of them: San Francisco, which is busier than ever, New York, Miami, and Tel Aviv. All four are very busy. Miami is new for us, and it’s been a refreshing addition. We’ve found a number of great companies there. A number of companies have moved over, primarily from Israel, but some have come down from New York or across the ocean. It’s a new hub, and it seems to be growing even more.

We just had the announcement that Ken Griffin is donating several billion dollars to help expand Carnegie Mellon, both in Pittsburgh and with a new campus in the Wynwood area of Miami, which will be fantastic. We’ve been calling for things like that for a while. Steve Ross is helping build a STEM-oriented graduate school for Vanderbilt in West Palm Beach. So on Florida’s southeast coast, we’re going to have a number of institutions producing great engineers and graduate students, and attracting the kind of industry we’re more familiar with in Silicon Valley. That’s very exciting.

I would say a lot of people are in Florida for the lifestyle, but they’re not there for retirement. They’re there to work and build companies and grow, sometimes remote, sometimes in a larger office. It’s not like Texas, where you can have 10,000 people on a campus, like a Dell. Florida typically has smaller organizations, more financial, more ownership and leadership, where not everybody in the organization has to be there.

Remember, it’s also a hub for Latin America. Even if you’re traveling across Latin America, most flights come through Miami to transfer people, luggage, and freight. So Miami will continue to prosper and grow in the international realm, the financial realm, and the tech realm. We have the Space Coast just to the north, Cape Canaveral and so on, these great universities starting, and Palantir just moved to Miami. So we have a lot going on. I don’t want to be chauvinistic about it. I want all ecosystems to prosper. But it’s nice to see a new one pop up on the screen like Miami, and we wish it well.

Steve Brotman:

Yeah. Actually, I think I just read that Vanderbilt is going to West Palm.

David Blumberg:

That’s what I said, yes. Steve Ross has really done a lot of the work in promoting it, bringing it there, and being very philanthropic and generous.

Steve Brotman:

Let’s shift gears to entrepreneurs.

David Blumberg:

Yes.

Steve Brotman:

What do you see in an entrepreneur in the first 10 minutes that tells you to keep going?

David Blumberg:

Excellent question. I look for somebody with charisma trying to solve a hard problem that’s important. That’s a really big part of what we’re looking for. We want somebody with drive, ambition, persistence, and grit, because being an entrepreneur is not easy. You and I know this. We both started our own firms, so we know it’s not linear. There are a lot of ups and downs. It’s a rollercoaster life, and yet it’s very rewarding.

Remember I was telling you about the early days at Check Point. It was so exciting. I would work 18-hour days and not be tired. I was exhilarated. The adrenaline you get from bringing something new to market, helping people solve problems, and saying, “Wow, we’ve got something that can solve that for you,” is very fulfilling, very exciting, and very dynamic.

With entrepreneurs, we look for what we call the six Ts. I’ll go through them quickly, if that’s okay.

Steve Brotman:

I like it.

David Blumberg:

I borrowed this from Neil Weintraub, another well-known VC, and I’ve edited it a little along the way. He’s moved to the East Coast, and he also lives in the Palm Beach area. He’s a terrific guy.

The first T is the theme: what is the problem you’re trying to solve? Tell us why it’s an important problem, why it’s big, and so on.

Then the team. Who’s doing this, and why are you the right folks? It’s usually not one person. It’s usually a team of two, three, or four people starting something, because nobody’s good at everything. Often one of you is better at technology and somebody else is better at sales, or one of you is better at finance and somebody else at technology. We look at the team and ask, “If there are holes, how can we help fill them?” Don’t try to bluff us and say, “We’ve got everybody, and we’re all set.” If you have weaknesses or areas where you need to add people, tell us. We have recruiters. We’re there to help bring people in for you.

Next is the terrain. That’s our T word for the market. What we’re looking for is a dynamic understanding of how the market is evolving and changing. Are there technological changes we need to know about? Demographic changes? Compliance and regulatory issues? All of those matter for how the company evolves over time, because if we invest in 2026, the exit might not come for another six, eight, 10, or 12 years. So we want to understand how things will change by the time you’d want an exit.

On terrain, we like things like Harvey ball charts. A Harvey ball chart lists competitors down one axis and product features across the other. A full Harvey ball means that feature is completely covered by that product. A half means you’re not as good. Empty means you have nothing in that category. It gives you a really good comparison of how you stack up against a rival’s product. We also like spider charts. The center, the zero axis, means no strength, and the further out you are, the stronger you are in that category. You might be strong in functionality, speed, accuracy, price, whatever, and you pull the chart out where you’re strong and leave it close to the center where you’re weak. Those are interesting charts. That’s the terrain.

Then there’s the technology. We need to know how it works, what’s novel, and what’s difficult for others to copy, so you have a sustainable edge.

The next T is traction, which is about where you are in the journey. Are you pre-product? Do you have any code written? We deal mostly with software, but this can apply to anything. Or do you have customers and a first round of financing? Where are you on the journey of building the business? As you build the business and reduce the risk, your valuation generally goes up.

The last T is the terms. How much money is needed? How much runway will it give you? Is there a particular board construction you’re interested in, and are there other terms that are important to you?

So to recap: the theme, what problem you’re solving. The team, who’s going to do it. The terrain, where you are in the market cycle and its dynamics. The technology, how it works. The traction, where you are in the journey. And the terms, how much you need and how we can help.

Steve Brotman:

It’s funny. Do you score those on a one to 10 basis?

David Blumberg:

Yeah, we have a kind of scoring methodology. We’re using AI, so we’re eating our own dog food, as we say. We have scoring technology that helps us look at plans that come in over the transom or are referred by people. We obviously meet people and get a lot of this data ourselves through interaction. And we’re now also using AI outbound to find entrepreneurs. 47% of our deal flow comes from our own outbound initiative: going to universities, going to trade shows, being active on GitHub, and so on, finding folks and saying, “This looks interesting. Can we talk to you?”

Steve Brotman:

That’s interesting. You’re more like an airline pilot checking the switches to make sure you’re set for landing than an artist who gazes up and says, “Oh.” It sounds like there’s a bit of that, but you try to bring it down to analytics, and you train your team on what’s a six and what’s a four. You use 10 points?

David Blumberg:

Yeah.

Steve Brotman:

And what do you need to score to be “all systems go”?

David Blumberg:

I don’t know. It probably varies, and some of the team are probably deeper into the actual numbers. But you know the good ones when you see them. I knew instantly that Nutanix was going to be big. I knew DoubleVerify was going to be big, because these were big ideas. Most of them were in virgin territory. There was nothing exactly similar, so they were filling a big, open gap in the market. They were very charismatic, determined entrepreneurs, and not necessarily charismatic in a showbiz kind of way. They’re techy, geeky folks, but they could talk to a CIO or a CISO sincerely and with authoritative knowledge about solving a problem.

That’s really what people are looking for. People don’t have a lot of time to waste, especially at large technology customers. You need to get to the point of the problem right away and say, “Here’s what I’ve got. I think we can solve problem X, Y, Z for you. Here’s how it works, here are the competitors, here are our advantages, and here’s why you might want to consider us.” That’s what we like to see. It’s gratifying to work with those teams and help them, not only with money, but with new customers, new hires, strategic advice, marketing help, and so on.

Steve Brotman:

And what’s the biggest red flag you’ve ever seen? What’s something a founder should never do?

David Blumberg:

I don’t like arrogance. I find a lot of VCs particularly arrogant, without really deserving it, because we’re not the stars. You and I are not the stars. The stars are the entrepreneurs. We’re like honeybees pollinating a lot of flowers, but the flowers are the stars of the show. The entrepreneurs are really the ones doing this.

Steve Brotman:

And the fruit that they bear.

David Blumberg:

Exactly right. That’s the metaphor I was going for. So I don’t like arrogance. I like humility. I like hardworking, hard-driving people.

I’ll give you the example of one of the companies we’ve recently invested in. The founders are three brothers. They’re refugees from a war-torn country. Their family suffered terrible violence in their native country, and they had to come to North America as refugees. They’re the most patriotic, humble, hardworking team, and they get along so well. I look at my boys and say, “Hey, I want you guys to be like this trio of founders.” That’s very gratifying to see, because humans like to see people cooperating toward a greater goal. When you see it in a team that’s really bonded, where each one knows their place, it’s like being on a submarine. Everyone has to be firing on all cylinders, because submarine decisions are snap decisions, and if you make a mistake, it could be fatal.

So you asked what we like and what we don’t like. What we don’t like is when founders make stuff up, try to BS us, lie, or dissemble about the numbers or the reasons for a delay, or something of that nature. It’s much better to be straightforward and tell us what’s going on, because then we can be part of your team and help you. If you’re telling us X when the help is really needed at Y, we’re going to aim in the wrong direction, and it’s not going to help you.

Steve Brotman:

Let’s switch gears and talk about LPs. What do you think LPs get wrong about early stage venture?

David Blumberg:

Excellent question, and very top of mind right now. When I’m talking to LPs, I’m talking about the amazing productivity gains we’re seeing, and there’s been an unlock recently. Remember, most people in the LP world are looking in the rearview mirror. They’re looking at the past and treating it as a prediction of the future. But if we look at the present, there’s been a dramatic unlock.

At Blumberg Capital alone, and we’re just one fund, we’ve had three exits over $2 billion in the last three months. We’ve invested in three of the fastest-growing companies we’ve ever seen in the last three months, and we’ve had five markups of over 100% across the portfolio, so our TVPI is marking up.

I think the LP community is still suffering from a bit of shock, from a kind of thirst. Not starvation exactly, but a dry period for DPI. There hasn’t been a lot of distribution of invested capital. I’m seeing that start to unlock again in our portfolio, and I think in others. But since 2022, interest rates went up dramatically, which caused another J-curve. A lot of companies that were planning to go public had to pull back, and some companies scaled down their growth plans. So the LP community is saying, “Venture’s not that great. It hasn’t returned money in five or six years, and we’re turned off.”

Just yesterday I talked to a very large pension fund. I won’t say the name or even where they are, other than somewhere in North America. They said, “We haven’t done much in venture in the past few years, because we did a lot from 2019 to 2022.” So they were investing at the height of the bubble-ish period, and they were investing a lot in Asia, particularly China, and it didn’t work out so well. I said to them, “We’re a very different kettle of fish. The times are very different, the geography is very different, and the outlook is very different. Here are some examples of incredible exits happening now with amazing, growing companies. They’re very stable. They’re not fluffy. They’re not going to be knocked off by some quick new trend or a change of style or mood, and they’re not going to be upended by regulation, as far as I can see.”

There’s a lot of real, steady demand for this new agentic AI. The difference with agentic AI, if I may, Steve, is that it’s about productivity, and the productivity gains are palpable, significant, and relatively quick to achieve.

I’ll give you an example from an investor in our fund. He’s not one of our portfolio companies, he’s one of our LPs. He has a loan consolidation business. If you have four or five credit cards, some of them overdue, and you’re paying too much on each one, his team will call you and say, “You have four or five credit cards, and some are overdue. We can get them all into one account at a lower interest rate, and that’ll help you.” Each employee can negotiate about 12 of these per week. They went out to San Francisco and got an AI consulting group to build a bot that does this, I think in Spanish and English. They put it into effect several months ago, and in its first week on the job, it negotiated 126 of these, soup to nuts, end to end, instead of the 12 an average person could do.

That’s a 10X gain in productivity, and we’re seeing that across so many domains: legal work, accounting work, insurance work, you name it. That’s very powerful. But we’re not seeing a lot of layoffs. In fact, I think the US economy has added over a million jobs since January 2021, and we actually have lower unemployment right now than we did previously. Things are getting better, and I think it’s because people are becoming more productive. The only way wages can actually rise for average people is if their productivity goes up.

A simple example: if you were sewing clothes by hand, I could pay you X. If I give you a sewing machine, that’s a capital investment on my part, built on the intellectual property of the people who invented the sewing machine. You’re going to produce a lot more clothing, and I can pay you more. Does that make sense? That’s the way the world works, and most people don’t seem to understand it, especially our politicians.

I’d just like people to give credit where credit is due. Capital investment is good, and it can be in equipment or in IP. The key thing we’re seeing from the AI revolution is this amazing power to give our minds machines. We gave machines to our factories, and before that, we gave machines to our farms. Now we’re giving machines to our minds, and that embodies a bright new future, because people are going to be more productive and do things they’ve never been able to do before. We’ll spend less time wasted on logging in, cutting and pasting, and the mundane tasks that take time but don’t deliver much value. Now the bots can do that, and we can move on to more productive work.

Steve Brotman:

Let me rephrase it, and maybe this is wrong: the DPI problem is quickly resolving on its own. Is that accurate?

David Blumberg:

I think so. We’re seeing evidence of it now. The SpaceX IPO was great, and I think there will be others coming along.

Steve Brotman:

Rehydrating.

David Blumberg:

Here’s an interesting point, if I may. We envision two waves. The first wave is the great companies of recent decades, like Apple, Google, Facebook, and Oracle. Pick your companies from 10, 20, or 30 years ago. Those companies went public when they were relatively small, and they grew 1,000 times in value as public companies. So that thousandfold alpha, to use the name of your fund, could be captured by the public markets, whether by retail investors or by ETFs and index funds.

In the recent era, take Databricks, Stripe, Anthropic, Anduril, OpenAI, and until recently, SpaceX. All the others are still private. Those companies grew to hundreds of billions or trillions in value before going public. So public market investors, with a typical 60/40 portfolio in a 401(k) or a pension fund, don’t participate in that growth. What I think, and I think you probably agree, is that we need to tell LPs: shift left. Move earlier. Get more exposure to early stage venture, because these companies are growing really fast, and you’re going to miss a lot of the gain if you wait until they’re public. That’s a big move.

Steve Brotman:

Absolutely. I think a lot of LPs, at least in early stage, misjudge the duration and misjudge what the asset class is. It’s not a bond.

David Blumberg:

That’s right.

Steve Brotman:

It’s a wealth generator. It doesn’t throw off cash, and if you don’t want to play that game, you shouldn’t play it.

David Blumberg:

That’s right. If you want private credit and yield, that’s fine, and you should have that for part of your portfolio. But incredible wealth creation really comes from capital gains.

Steve Brotman:

If you have 10 GPs and none of them are giving you enough DPI, maybe the GPs aren’t the problem. It could be an asset class issue. But I agree with you that the tempo is up. AI speeds everything up, and companies are growing faster. A B2B SaaS company took 10 years on average to get to $100 million.

David Blumberg:

That’s right.

Steve Brotman:

Now they’re getting there in two or three years, sometimes in one.

David Blumberg:

Exactly right. That’s exactly what I meant to say, so thank you for restating it more clearly.

Steve Brotman:

All right, shifting gears a little more. You mentioned longer durations, though they might become shorter.

David Blumberg:

Yes, both.

Steve Brotman:

On co-investing, pro rata rights, and later rounds: 95% of VCs don’t do their B rounds or later.

David Blumberg:

Which is where you come in, yes.

Steve Brotman:

Which is where we come in. But how do you think about it? You have a growth fund, and you have LPs that want pro rata. How do you handle that?

David Blumberg:

Excellent question. On these growth paths, where a company grows over five, 10, sometimes 15 years, the nice thing about today versus when you and I were a lot younger, say 30 years ago, is that there wasn’t much of a secondary market then. The secondary market has really come to the fore.

For example, with the health insurance company I was just talking about, we’re selling a third of our position. It’s been marked up dramatically. This one position is worth more than our whole fund, so we’re going to sell a third of it, send that back to the LPs, and carry forward with about two-thirds remaining, which we think will grow very substantially from here.

We’ve done this historically with other companies, some of which you mentioned. With DoubleVerify, a private equity acquirer came in to take control before the IPO. All the other VCs sold everything. We only sold part of our position, because we felt DoubleVerify’s future was better than its present, and we wanted to hold on. We were rewarded: most other folks returned about 3 to 8X on that investment, and we got 73X after it went public and we distributed. We did it with Nutanix, where I think we sold 10% of our shares before the IPO. We did it with Braze, where we sold about 50 million out of 300. And we did it with Hootsuite in a pure secondary. It never went public, but we sold to large acquiring investors like Accel and OMERS.

So that’s a good thing. Number one, if you’re an early stage investor, you can sell along the way to like-minded investors who are coming in later. Number two, I think it’s gone in two directions. The regulation and cost of an IPO has slowed things down, so some companies take longer to go public. On the other hand, with the AI revolution, we’re seeing very fast growth, like the company in our portfolio that went from zero revenue in November to a $300 million run rate by July, and another that went from $20 million last July to over $300 million this July. We have not seen that kind of growth before, and I think it will enable us either to do secondary sales along the way or to have quicker exits, because with growth that enormous, companies can get acquired or, hopefully, go public in a shorter period of time.

And then there’s your firm, and I want to give you a shout-out. You’re playing a very important role, and we’d like to do more with you. We’ve gone to our LPs and offered SPVs. The problem for them is that they often don’t have the time or the staff to evaluate those opportunities themselves. Sometimes they’ll just say, “David, should I invest?” And I’ll say, “Generally, yes. I’m investing personally as well. My money’s in there alongside yours.” That’s often good enough for them. But your firm plays an interesting role, because you’re a professional. You can underwrite, you probably take a bit more time, your checks are clear, and you share upside with folks like us. So it’s very attractive both ways. I like that model, and thank you for filling the gap.

Steve Brotman:

It’s been an interesting run, David, thanks to friends like you. We’ve looked at 12 deals together, and it looks like there are three or four we should have done. I’m pinging my team on Slack: “What the heck? What did we do wrong?”

David Blumberg:

Let’s get our teams together. We have geographic overlap. You have people on the East Coast, in Florida and New York, and so do we, and then San Francisco. We can get together there. And you have an office in Tel Aviv now, so you can look at all of our companies anytime you want.

Steve Brotman:

One last question. How has your LP base evolved?

David Blumberg:

Just the LPs?

Steve Brotman:

Yeah. Has it been mostly institutional, family offices, big family offices?

David Blumberg:

It started off mostly family offices. Now it’s diversified. We have a large international bank, healthcare endowments, community endowments, university endowments, and an international pension fund. So it’s a variety, but I’d say the largest bulk is large single-family offices or multi-family offices. They’ll often bring together 10 or 20 families and act as the spigot, controlling the capital calls and distributions on their behalf, and they do the vetting.

We’re happy with any and all. We’d like to get some strategics. If there’s anybody in a large corporation listening to this, that’s an interesting group for us to have as well, because we love the interaction with large corporations that need technology. We’re looking at so much, and we like that give and take.

Steve Brotman:

Amazing. We’re going to see each other at Milken,

David Blumberg:

Yes, in Singapore.

Steve Brotman:

which could be pretty interesting. I went there

David Blumberg:

Best food.

Steve Brotman:

Yeah. Let’s break out some time while we’re there and kibitz a little more. This has been a fascinating conversation. We could spend the next four or five hours chatting, and that’s what inspired me to start this podcast. You and I get to have these conversations about some of the most important things facing companies, our country, our globe, our culture, everything. It’s the best job in the world to be able to chat with people like you. So thanks.

David Blumberg:

You’re very kind. I think you’re very wise to do this kind of podcast, not just with me but with many people, because it gives you the opportunity to have a dialogue and build relationships. I think we might want to copy your good example.

Steve Brotman:

Please do. I think VCs talking more publicly humanizes us a bit,

David Blumberg:

Indeed.

Steve Brotman:

and makes us all a bit more approachable. I think that’s super important in today’s world, where trust is at a premium. So I appreciate your thoughts and comments here. As I said, I think we could chat forever.

David Blumberg:

Anytime, brother. I’d like to be with you on the plane to Singapore. That’d be a long chat, but I think you’re going a day later.

Steve Brotman:

I’m going to the dinner.

David Blumberg:

See you there, then.

Steve Brotman:

Thanks so much, David, for joining the pod, and we’ll chat soon. Thanks a lot.

David Blumberg:

You’re a great interviewer. Thank you.

Subscribe to Driving Alpha wherever you listen to podcasts.

Spotify LogoApple Podcasts LogoYouTube Logo